Friday, August 18, 2017

Supremacy, monuments, and movements

I wake up this morning while on vacation saddened and fearful, both at what has brought us to this point as a nation and what the consequences may be with numerous white supremacist rallies planned for this weekend across the country.  However, I am also proud of the many true Americans lending their voice to the charge against senseless bigotry and racism.  Please allow me to make a few points:

The President:  I still see people standing by the President's remarks and sentiments.  But, luckily, there are many more that realize the gravity of what he has put forth.  It upsets me to say, but there will most likely be violent clashes at these rallies.  Engaging physically in this manner is not the way to solve any of these problems.  What is even more sad, is that supporters will use this to say that Trump was right instead of realizing that he is the largest reason that the number of clashes are happening and growing.  A leader must understand the psyche of his people, how his words will resonate with various groups, and stand on the pinnacle of moral and ethical grounds. 

But, you may say, 'he condemned the groups and people refuse to see that'.  When the head of the KKK comes out to publicly thank him for the remarks, the speech did not reach the mark.  A true leader, seeing this, would have immediately come out again to clarify and truly condemn seeing that the initial statement didn't reach it's intended goal.

Our country valiantly stood up and fought against the Nazis and white supremacists and what they stood for in WWII.  Those are the soldiers that SHOULD have statues erected in honor of them.  Our ancestors risked their lives, and many ultimately gave their lives, to defend us from the ideals that these groups propose to put forth. 

For these reasons, it is the president, who should be the unifier of this country, who is now causing this clash to escalate.  He has emboldened the Nazis, white supremacists, and KKK on one side, while also, without saying it outright, challenged the violent on the far left to do something about it.  It's simple psychology and he could have, and should have, been able to denounce the one while making the charge of peaceful protest to the other, but his hollow words don't come off that way.  In the meantime, those true Americans who stand up for our values of equality and justice for all also feel the need to make their case and are caught in the middle.

Monuments:  Speaking of monuments, let's delve into that aspect of current events.  Many are saying this all comes down to protecting our history and monuments.  If that were the case, then why were there chants of anti-Semitic and white supremacist nature and why were the hate groups largely involved.  No, it gave an excuse to mobilize and shows why the monuments were a problem in the first place.  As we can see, the protests also have backfired as many cities are removing these statues and monuments after what happened.

Are we getting rid of our history by doing so, though?  No, that's absolutely ridiculous.  Saying that books will be burned next, or that people will want the pyramids removed, or, as Trump did, that George Washington monuments will be next just shows your lack of understanding.  The last thing those that are fighting for this want is for people to forget what happened!  It's important to have books and education on this important period of our history, lest we be doomed to repeat it.  And, comparing a national hero who had slaves consistent with his times, although not consistent with our current values but who also happened to free them, with those who fought against our very own country with slavery being a major component of that fight again shows a deep lack of understanding and appreciation.

These monuments aren't about education or teaching history.  They were erected to glorify the confederates and what they stood for.  In addition, they were put in place, not right after the civil war, but mostly during times of oppression in the Jim Crow era.  Imagine seeing a monument honoring a kamikaze in Honolulu, or a German WWII soldier in our nations capital.  But, these weren't American citizens you say.  Okay, look up the history of Benedict Arnold monuments and how the public and military has fought to keep his name off of any depictions.

Movements:  I've also seen many supporters try to compare the white supremacist movement to the black lives matter movement.  Some who claim to denounce recent actions are saying in the same breath that the white supremacists don't speak for them just like black lives matter doesn't.  There is a major flaw here.  There is no comparison.  One is rightfully saying that they want their race to be treated as equal, to not be discriminated against, and for the law to be applied the same for them as it is for other races.  The other is saying our race is superior and we want to continue to have our special privileges over other races.  To compare the two is plain ignorance, and when they start chanting white lives matter or calling their marches white lives matter, it is only showing the derogatory nature of their stance instead of any semblance of honorable charge.

I could go on, but will refrain from doing so.  My message to you is this:  People are created equal.  If you feel otherwise, try to engage in civil discourse with those of other cultures and understand their history and background.  Do this on a personal level instead of making judgements based on editorials or articles.  Take classes or work on community projects where you have to team up toward a common goal.  Don't hate.  The fight for supremacy will always ultimately lose to the fight for equality, for the face of supremacy from one demographic to another across the globe is vastly different while the face of equality is universal.  Finally, your collective voices and peaceful actions will almost always reign supreme against threats and violence; be intelligent in fighting the good fight.


6 comments:

  1. Very well said. Lived through the 60's and was never afraid. Now I am. This could so easily get out of control.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well written Dave there are some concerns once again on my part in a couple areas where I feel you are limited on the information of what is going on. The paragraph where you blast the BLM movement and the Supremacist movement. I agree that most of the people that participate in the BLM movements you are exactly right and there is nothing to compare. They are out there trying to still fight for more equality and rightly so, but here is a link to the BLM charter. After you read through this link and the see the extremism that the people who created BLM want to take their movement, it may just shed some light on some folks reaction. Once again I highly doubt 95% of the people who have marched in BLM protests are aware of some of these issues addressed on their website, but they are the posted desires of the BLM movement. https://policy.m4bl.org/platform/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, John. I know about that aspect of the BLM movement and, of course, don't agree with their actions. But, like you said, they are a very small minority of the movement and thus shouldn't change what the goal is for most. There's almost always going to be extremes in any large group and I try look at the overall message and direction they are heading. Trust me, I am not limited in my information. I read a lot and post my beliefs based on facts as I see them. Just because they may seem to line up one way or another doesn't mean that I've only read one side. In fact, if I post something, it's usually because I have read so much misinformation that I feel compelled to add my voice.

      Delete
  3. On what Trump has said here recently and what he has tweeted, he is just not socially cut out for the job of President. (I did not vote for him, but I am happy Hilary is not president either) The things the media is putting out there that he is a white supremacist is totally a lie by our left wing media. YOu can google search this on your own it pops up with a simple search of Trump and Reform Party. The Reform Party is the party that was created by Ross Perot in the late 90's and Trump was kicking the idea of running for President back then under the reform party ticket. There is an interview of Trump on one of the major news networks after he pulled out of that notion. When he was asked by the reporter why he pulled out Trumps response was David Duke just joined this party along with Mike Huckabee and they are both radical in their beliefs (paraphrased but in general what he said. As I watch him and what is going on I think he allied with Steve Bannon because he knew the power that Bannon carries with manipulation of the press.

    I feel it should be said I started off not voting for Trump and at one point in time I was going to vote for Trump because of my dislike of the Clinton's, but when Trump named Bannon as his head of whatever during the election and gave us insight that Bannon was going to be his chief of staff, that is when I was actually out campaigning for Gary Johnson. Bannon is an awful person, like George Soros awful.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I haven't called Trump a supremacist himself. I personally believe that he's just an extremely poor leader and failed to see how negatively his actions and words would sit with the large majority of Americans.

      Delete
  4. I think this is about to get even more interesting. When he fired Bannon ( who is the media mogul and in my opinion a racist) I am curious to see what starts coming out on Trump. I dont think Bannon is going to take his firing laying down. It is one of about a half a dozen things Trump has done that I agree with, when he fired Bannon.

    ReplyDelete